Select Page

Hypothesis testing

H8 – Digital Displacement, Built–Natural Gradients, SDI Ordering, and Education Moderation Across Maslow Need Levels

H8a (Digital Belonging↑ / Self-Actualisation↓ with TDM) 

H1: Higher Technology & Digital Media (TDM) weight is positively associated with Love & Belonging (LB) and negatively associated with Self-Actualisation (SA), controlling for Built and Humans.

H0: TDM has no association with LB or SA after controls.

H8b (Built gradient across need levels (downward slope)) 

H1: The association of Built Structures & Indoor/Urban Spaces with need salience declines as you move up the Maslow ladder.

H0: No monotone change across levels.

H8c (Natural gradient across need levels (upward slope)) 

H1: The association of Natural Landscapes & Phenomena increases with need level.

H0: No monotone change across levels.

H8d (Education moderation) 

H1: Educational contexts amplify the TDM shift (stronger TDM×Edu negative for SA) and flatten Natural’s upward trend.

H0:No moderation by education.

 

Question:

Do Technology & Digital Media, Built Structures, and Natural Landscapes differ in how they relate to Maslow need levels, and are these patterns moderated by educational contexts?

Data

Data subset:

All 10 Developmental Affordance (DA) groups and all 6 Maslow need levels from the full corpus. No temporal filters. Inclusion rule: images were retained if they had at least one DA or at least one Maslow category present after merge and cleaning (deduplicated at image × category).

Variables:

    • Predictors (DA groups): Technology & Digital Media (TDM), Built Structures & Indoor/Urban Spaces (Built), Natural Landscapes & Phenomena (Natural), Humans.
    • Outcomes (Maslow): Love & Belonging (LB), Self-Actualisation (SA); levelwise analyses use all six Maslow levels (L1–L6).
    • Controls: Category fixed effects (FEs); Humans included alongside TDM/Built/Natural in relevant models.

    Normalisation & Weighting: See WWeighted Calculation Methods reference page.

    N: 6,7890

    (Acronyms: LB = Love & Belonging; SA = Self-Actualisation; TDM = Technology & Digital Media; FDR = false discovery rate–adjusted p; “β” = regression coefficient.)

    Methods

    • H8a (Digital displacement): Multiple regression using Weighted Least Squares (WLS) on proportional outcomes, Binary GLM (logit) on presence/absence, and Quantile Regression (QR) at q = 0.25/0.50/0.75 with bootstrap CIs. All models include category FEs; WLS uses cluster-robust SEs by category.
    • H8b/H8c (Gradients across levels): Levelwise WLS: for each Maslow level, regress the level outcome on Built (H8b) or Natural (H8c) controlling for Humans + FEs. (Trend lines across levels are estimated in the scripts; results below focus on the levelwise coefficients you surfaced.)
    • H8d (Education moderation): WLS with interactions (TDM×Edu, Natural×Edu), plus simple slopes for TDM at Edu=0 vs Edu=1.
    • Multiple testing: Benjamini–Hochberg FDR within model families; only FDR-significant effects are reported in the main tables.

    Results — H8a Digital Belonging↑ / Self-Actualisation↓ with TDM

    Outcome: Love & Belonging (LB)

    Model Predictor β [95% CI] FDR-p Notes
    WLS (cluster) TDM 0.210 [0.160, 0.260] 3.06e-16 Positive association
    WLS (cluster) Built 0.052 [0.021, 0.083] 0.00102 Positive
    WLS (cluster) Humans 0.189 [0.161, 0.217] 4.02e-39 Positive
    Binary (logit) Built 0.827 [0.578, 1.075] 1.44e-10 Presence ↑ odds of LB
    Binary (logit) Humans 2.818 [2.527, 3.109] 2.91e-79 Presence ↑↑ odds of LB
    QR (q=0.75) TDM 0.385 [0.330, 0.442] — Strongest at upper LB
    QR (q=0.50) Built 0.100 [0.056, 0.117] — Median LB
    QR (q=0.75) Built 0.118 [0.074, 0.158] — Upper LB
    QR (q=0.25/0.50/0.75) Humans 0.167 / 0.267 / 0.327 ([0.154, 0.179] / [0.250, 0.290] / [0.291, 0.346]) — Positive at all quantiles

    TDM, Built, and Humans are each positively associated with LB; TDM’s effect is largest at the upper part of the LB distribution (q=0.75).

     

    Outcome: Self-Actualisation (SA)

    Model Predictor β [95% CI] FDR-p Notes
    WLS (cluster) TDM −0.182 [−0.246, −0.118] 3.22e-08 Negative association
    WLS (cluster) Built −0.089 [−0.147, −0.030] 0.00322 Negative
    WLS (cluster) Humans −0.295 [−0.350, −0.239] 5.94e-25 Negative
    Binary (logit) TDM −0.709 [−0.939, −0.479] 2.40e-09 Presence ↓ odds of SA
    Binary (logit) Built +0.154 [0.004, 0.303] 0.0498 Small positive (presence)
    Binary (logit) Humans −0.269 [−0.523, −0.015] 0.0498 Negative
    QR (q=0.50) TDM / Built / Humans −0.416 / −0.117 / −0.331 (CIs all negative) — Median SA
    QR (q=0.75) TDM / Built / Humans −0.218 / −0.187 / −0.464 (CIs all negative) — Upper SA

    TDM is negatively associated with SA across WLS, Binary, and QR. Built is largely negative for SA in WLS/QR, with a small positive effect in the presence model a common divergence between proportional vs. binary outcomes.

    Results – H8b — Built gradient across need levels (downward)

    Levelwise WLS β for Built, controlling Humans + FEs. Only FDR-significant levels are shown.

    Maslow Level β [95% CI] FDR-p Direction
    L1 Physiological +0.121 [0.072, 0.170] 4.28e-06 Over-represented
    L2 Safety −0.046 [−0.066, −0.025] 2.18e-05 Under-represented
    L6 Self-Transcendence −0.068 [−0.087, −0.049] 5.44e-12 Under-represented

    Built is high at lower needs (L1) and suppressed at the top (L6), consistent with a downward gradient across levels.

     

    H8c — Natural gradient across need levels (upward)

    Levelwise WLS β for Natural, controlling Humans + FEs. All levels were FDR-significant.

     

    Maslow Level β [95% CI] FDR-p Direction
    L1 Physiological −0.163 [−0.213, −0.113] 3.16e-10 Under-represented
    L2 Safety −0.090 [−0.122, −0.058] 5.20e-08 Under-represented
    L3 Love & Belonging −0.157 [−0.195, −0.119] 1.41e-15 Under-represented
    L4 Esteem −0.101 [−0.140, −0.061] 6.39e-07 Under-represented
    L5 Self-Actualisation +0.335 [0.263, 0.408] 7.22e-19 Over-represented
    L6 Self-Transcendence +0.175 [0.127, 0.223] 1.89e-12 Over-represented

    Natural is suppressed at lower levels (L1–L4) and elevated at higher levels (L5–L6), i.e., a strong upward gradient.

     

    H8d — Education moderation (amplified TDM shift; altered Natural pattern)

    WLS with interactions; cluster-robust by category.

    Outcome Term β [95% CI] FDR-p Interpretation
    LB TDM×Edu +0.225 [0.170, 0.280] 1.34e-15 TDM’s pro-LB effect is stronger in education images
    SA TDM×Edu −0.150 [−0.217, −0.082] 1.73e-05 TDM’s anti-SA effect is stronger in education images
    LB Natural×Edu −0.112 [−0.132, −0.092] 6.06e-28 Natural’s LB association is dampened in education
    SA Natural×Edu +0.557 [0.512, 0.602] 1.92e-130 Natural’s SA association is enhanced in education

    Simple slopes for TDM (derived from main + interaction):

    • LB: TDM at Edu=0 → +0.204; at Edu=1 → +0.204 + 0.225 = +0.429.
    • SA: TDM at Edu=0 → −0.175; at Edu=1 → −0.175 − 0.150 = −0.325.

    Education amplifies the digital displacement pattern (LB↑, SA↓ with TDM). Natural’s role in education flips by outcome LB is dampened while SA is strengthened.

    Combined Interpretation

    Across 6,789 images (category-balanced), we see a coherent “digital displacement” pattern and complementary built–natural gradients:

    Digital displacement (H8a):

        • Technology & Digital Media (TDM) is pro-belonging and anti-self-actualisation even after controls.
        • In WLS, TDM → LB↑ (β≈0.21, 95% CI [0.16, 0.26]) and SA↓ (β≈−0.18, [−0.25, −0.12]); Binary and QR agree directionally (e.g., QR q=.75 for LB: β≈0.39; QR q=.50 for SA: β≈−0.42).
        • Built and Humans show a similar split—LB positive, SA negative—though magnitudes differ by model.

    This indicates that screens/indoor cues and people cues are associated with belonging needs rather than self-actualisation.

     

    Built–natural gradients (H8b/H8c):

        • Built is over-represented at low needs and under-represented at high needs (e.g., L1 Physiological β≈+0.12; L6 Self-Transcendence β≈−0.07), consistent with a downward slope across the Maslow ladder.
        • Natural flips that pattern: under-represented at lower levels (L1–L4 all negative) but over-represented at higher levels (L5 SA β≈+0.34; L6 ST β≈+0.18), i.e., a clear upward slope.

    These complementary gradients fit a narrative where indoor/urban cues cluster with more immediate, social or security needs, while nature cues align with growth/realisation needs.

     

    Education moderation (H8d):

        • Educational contexts amplify the TDM shift and alter the role of Natural:
        • TDM×Edu: stronger LB↑ (interaction β≈+0.23) and stronger SA↓ (β≈−0.15). Simple slopes: TDM→LB ≈ +0.20 (non-Edu) vs +0.43 (Edu); TDM→SA ≈ −0.18 (non-Edu) vs −0.33 (Edu).
        • Natural×Edu: LB↓ (β≈−0.11) and SA↑ (β≈+0.56) in education imagery.

    “Digital” signals in education strengthen the belonging-over-self-actualisation tilt, while “natural” signals in education suppress belonging and accentuate self-actualisation.

    Together, these results tell a consistent story: screen/indoor contexts and people emphasise connectedness and social inclusion, especially in education, whereas nature tracks higher-order growth needs—most clearly at Self-Actualisation and Self-Transcendence.

    Concluison

    H8a — Reject H₀. TDM is pro-Belonging and anti-Self-Actualisation: LB β≈0.21 (FDR p≈3e-16); SA β≈−0.18 (FDR p≈3e-08).

    H8b — Reject H₀. Built shows a downward gradient: positive at L1 (β≈+0.12, FDR p≈4e-06) and negative by L6 (β≈−0.07, FDR p≈5e-12).

    H8c — Reject H₀. Natural shows an upward gradient: negative at lower levels (e.g., L3 β≈−0.16, FDR p≈1e-15) but positive at higher levels (L5 β≈+0.34, FDR p≈7e-19).

    H8d — Reject H₀. Education strengthens the TDM pattern and shifts Nature by 

        • TDM×Edu → LB β≈+0.23 (FDR p≈1e-15), TDM×Edu → SA β≈−0.15 (FDR p≈2e-05).
        • Simple slopes for TDM: LB +0.20 → +0.43, SA −0.18 → −0.33 (non-Edu → Edu).
    ←→