Hypothesis testing
H7 – Selective Displacement of Psychological Needs in Digital, Built, and Social Contexts
H7a (Digital Displacement of Self-Actualisation by Social Belonging)
H1: Technology & Digital Media (TDM) imagery is positively associated with Love & Belonging and negatively associated with Self-Actualisation, even after controlling for Built Structures and Human presence.
H0: TDM imagery shows no systematic association with Love & Belonging or Self-Actualisation after controlling for Built Structures and Human presence.
H7b (Indoor- Natural trade off)
H1: Built Structures are negatively associated with Natural Landscapes within the DA composition.
H0:Built Structures show no consistent association with Natural Landscapes.
H7c (Human Presence bias Towarda Immediate Needs)
H1: Human presence is positively associated with Love & Belonging and Physiological Needs, and negatively associated with Self-Actualisation.
H0: Human presence shows no consistent association with Maslow need levels.
Question:
Do digital, built, and social contexts systematically reallocate the expression of psychological needs — favouring immediate connection and survival cues at the expense of self-fulfilment and nature-oriented affordances?
Data
Data subset:
All 10 Developmental Affordance (DA) groups and all 6 Maslow need levels from the full corpus. No temporal filters. Inclusion rule: images were retained if they had at least one DA or at least one Maslow category present after merge and cleaning (deduplicated at image × category).
Variables:
- Predictors: Weighted-normalised scores for Technology & Digital Media, Built Structures, Humans.
- Outcomes: Weighted-normalised scores for Physiological Needs, Safety Needs, Love & Belonging, Esteem Needs, Self-Actualisation, Self-Transcendence.
- Controls: Category fixed effects; row-mass weighting (inverse of images per category).
- Compositional Analysis: Centred log-ratio (CLR) transformation applied to relevant DA pairs (Built ↔ Natural; Humans ↔ Natural; TDM ↔ Natural); compositional structure inherently controls for other DA proportions.
Normalisation & Weighting: See WWeighted Calculation Methods reference page.
N: 6,789
Methods
- Weighted models: WLS with HC3-robust SEs and category fixed effects.
- Binary models: GLM (Binomial) with HC3 SEs, same predictors/outcomes as Weighted.
- Compositional models: Weighted Spearman correlation and CLR-OLS regression.
Results — H7a Digital Displacement of Self-Actualisation by Social Belonging
Weighted (WLS with FE, HC3)
| Outcome | Term | Coef | 95% CI | p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Love & Belonging | Technology & Digital Media | 0.210 | [0.167, 0.253] | < 1e-20 |
| Built Structures | 0.052 | [0.031, 0.073] | < 1e-5 | |
| Humans | 0.189 | [0.174, 0.204] | < 1e-100 | |
| Self-Actualisation | Technology & Digital Media | −0.182 | [−0.231, −0.133] | < 1e-12 |
| Built Structures | −0.089 | [−0.121, −0.056] | < 1e-7 | |
| Humans | −0.295 | [−0.316, −0.275] | < 1e-100 |
Binary (GLM, Binomial, HC3)
| Outcome | Term | Log-odds | 95% CI | p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Love & Belonging | Technology & Digital Media | −0.253 | [−15.19, 14.68] | 0.973 |
| Built Structures | 0.827 | [−11.02, 12.68] | 0.891 | |
| Humans | 2.818 | [−8.96, 14.60] | 0.639 | |
| Self-Actualisation | Technology & Digital Media | −0.709 | [−11.58, 10.16] | 0.898 |
| Built Structures | 0.154 | [−9.58, 9.89] | 0.975 | |
| Humans | −0.269 | [−10.26, 9.72] | 0.958 |
Compositional (DA↔DA)
No significant Built/TDM ↔ Natural displacement detected for TDM in compositional space.
Interpretation:
WLS shows strong selective displacement for TDM (belonging ↑, self-actualisation ↓), even controlling for built/human presence. Binary models are non-significant with wide CIs, though the TDM → Self-Actualisation sign matches WLS.
H7b – Indoor–Natural Trade-Off
Weighted (WLS with FE, HC3) – Physiological Needs outcome
| Term | Coef | 95% CI | p |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built Structures | 0.121 | [0.093, 0.149] | < 1e−16 |
| Humans | 0.298 | [0.280, 0.316] | < 1e−200 |
Binary (GLM Binomial, HC3) – Physiological Needs outcome
| Term | Log-odds | 95% CI | p |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built Structures | 0.989 | [−12.79, 14.77] | 0.888 |
| Humans | 3.588 | [−13.42, 20.59] | 0.679 |
Compositional (DA↔DA)
| Metric | Estimate | p |
|---|---|---|
| weighted Spearman ρ (clr(Built), clr(Natural)) | −0.084 | — |
| CLR-OLS: clr(Natural) ~ clr(Built) | −0.127 | 1.3e−29 |
Interpretation:
Built is positively associated with Physiological Needs in WLS (contrary to H7b prediction). Binary replication is non-significant. Compositional analysis confirms a strong negative Built–Natural relationship, indicating displacement of natural affordances by built content.
H7c – Human Presence Bias Toward Immediate Needs
Weighted (WLS with FE, HC3)
| Outcome | Term | Coef | 95% CI | p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Love & Belonging | Humans | 0.189 | [0.174, 0.204] | < 1e−100 |
| Physiological Needs | Humans | 0.298 | [0.280, 0.316] | < 1e−200 |
| Self-Actualisation | Humans | −0.295 | [−0.316, −0.275] | < 1e−100 |
Binary (GLM Binomial, HC3)
| Outcome | Term | Log-odds | 95% CI | p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Love & Belonging | Humans | 2.818 | [−8.96, 14.60] | 0.639 |
| Physiological Needs | Humans | 3.588 | [−13.42, 20.59] | 0.679 |
| Self-Actualisation | Humans | −0.269 | [−10.26, 9.72] | 0.958 |
Compositional (DA↔DA)
No significant Humans ↔ Natural displacement detected beyond what is accounted for in Built–Natural relationships.
Interpretation:
Weighted models show a strong bias toward immediate social and survival needs in human imagery, with reduced self-actualisation cues. Binary replication is non-significant but maintains directionality.
Combined Interpretation
Across H7a–H7c, the evidence indicates selective displacement rather than uniform suppression:
- TDM strongly increases belonging cues and decreases self-actualisation cues, independent of built/human factors.
- Built Structures replicate this displacement pattern at smaller magnitudes and are inversely related to natural affordances in composition.
- Human presence shows the strongest bias toward immediate needs, boosting physiological and belonging cues while suppressing self-actualisation.
These findings suggest that screen-centred, indoor, and socially dense contexts reallocate psychological need expression, privileging immediate connection and survival cues over long-term self-fulfilment and nature-oriented affordances.
Conclusion
H7a: Reject H₀ — Strong evidence that TDM imagery selectively displaces self-actualisation in favour of belonging.
H7b: Reject H₀ — Built content reliably displaces natural affordances in composition, despite mixed results on need-level displacement.
H7c: Reject H₀ — Human imagery favours immediate connection and survival cues over self-fulfilment.